Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

News

Supreme Court Refuses to Hear Lawsuit from Kari Lake on Voting Machines

The U.S. Supreme Court has shot down Kari Lake’s request to take up her ballot tabulator case that aimed to stop the use of the machines to count millions of Arizona ballots.

The highest court in the nation did not provide any comment on Monday when it denied the U.S. Senate hopeful’s petition to overturn the lower court’s decision to throw out her case.

Lake and fellow Republican Mark Finchem initially filed the suit in April 2022, while she was running for Arizona governor and he was running for secretary of state. They alleged that the electronic ballot tabulators used in Maricopa and Pima counties were “hackable” and that the courts should place an injunction on their use ahead of the November 2022 election, and instead force elections officials to count all the ballots by hand.

In August 2022, U.S. District Court Judge John Tuchi threw out the lawsuit and issued a scathing ruling. He later ordered $122,000 in sanctions against the attorneys in the case, saying that Lake and Finchem’s claims amounted to mere “conjectural allegations of potential injuries.”

In October 2023, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals concurred with Tuchi’s decision to reject the case, agreeing that it was “frivolous.”

“None of Plaintiffs’ allegations supported a plausible inference that their individual votes in future elections will be adversely affected by the use of electronic tabulation, particularly given the robust safeguards in Arizona law, the use of paper ballots, and the post-tabulation retention of those ballots,” the appellate court wrote.

Finchem and Lake, who both lost their 2022 bids for statewide office to Democrats, each filed lawsuits after that election seeking to overturn the results. In both cases, judges found that neither candidate could prove that there was any fraud, malfeasance or maladministration that changed the outcome.

In their petition to the Supreme Court, Lake and Finchem go as far as to accuse Arizona election officials of illegally altering the tabulator software — a crime under Arizona law — and concealing those alterations from the court when the case was originally filed.

They also claimed that Dominion Voting Systems equipment used in Maricopa County, and in many other counties across the country, “have a built-in security breach enabling malicious actors to take control of elections, likely without detection.”

The Arizona Republican Party — alongside the Georgia Republican Party and the Republican State Committee of Delaware — backed up Lake in her petition to SCOTUS, filing their own supporting brief earlier this month urging the court to take up the case.

The Virginia attorney representing the Republican parties, William J.Olson argued that, since 2020, state and federal courts across the U.S. began using what he called “unreasonable standards” to determine whether election cases have legal standing to move forward.

“The decision of the district court of Arizona to dismiss Petitioners’ challenge to the conduct of the 2022 Arizona election is one of the clearest illustrations of this abusive line of cases which have required much more than well-pled allegations, brought by candidates, that elections were being conducted in violation of law,” Olson wrote.

TOP STORIES

News

2 min readPresident Donald Trump gathered with House Republican leaders at the White House on Thursday to relay his tax priorities. In the meeting,...

News

2 min readAs of the start of this week, the Kremlin said ‘no progress’ had been made in arranging peace talks on Ukraine between...

News

3 min readU.S. government agencies have dropped a staggering $34 million in contracts with Virginia-based news outlet Politico, mostly on subscriptions, according to data...

News

4 min readKamala Harris gave a meandering, 179-word answer on Israel that “60 Minutes” cut to just 20 words, according to transcripts released Wednesday...

Advertisement